A letter of intent is a preliminary
document, generally prepared by an attorney, that memorializes
in writing some or all of the key deal points that negotiating
parties have agreed upon. Often pitched as "non-legal
binding", parties will sign such a document, feeling
that they have little or nothing to lose by doing so.
This article will discuss the benefits and risks to
consider when determining whether to use a letter of
intent for your next million dollar deal.
Why Use a Letter of Intent.
1. Commitment to preparation of an agreement.
More often as practical matter, there is a substantial
delay between the time the parties reach a verbal agreement
and the time when the verbal agreement is committed
to a signed written agreement. A delay can breed miscommunication
and encourages endless renegotiation of terms. Committing
the key terms to writing in the interim provides clarity
of agreed upon terms and encourages completion of the
transaction.
2. Exclusivity in negotiations.
While the drafting of the final agreement is pending,
a letter of intent is useful to commit the parties to
mutually exclusive dealings on the transaction. Exclusivity
in dealings avoids either party from suffering from
a feeling of insecurity, wondering whether the other
party will reject the deal to pursue other opportunities
or search for a more attractive deal while final drafting
is pending.
3. Information sharing.
A letter of intent can also address potential vulnerability
and exposure of confidential information exchanged during
the course of negotiations. The inclusion of a "Confidentiality
and Non-Disclosure" provision protects the parties and
encourages an open exchange of information.
4. Clarity for third parties.
A letter of intent can provide the necessary information
to provide to third parties to demonstrate the pending
transaction. It allows the parties to obtain approval
from boards of directors, loan committees, junior lien
holders etc. It is also useful when financing is required
prior to the consummation of the transaction.
Risks of Using a Letter of Intent
1. Contractual obligation.
One of the attractive elements of a letter of intent
is its purported non-binding nature. However, courts
can and will enforce letters of intent if (1) they are
convinced that the parties intended to be bound by the
agreement and (2) the agreement is sufficiently definite
to be enforced. Therefore, to assist and minimize judicial
interpretation, the parties should explicitly state
the binding or non-binding intent of the letter. Careful
drafting is critical and failure to be specific in the
binding or non-binding nature can dramatically increase
the parties litigation risk.
2. Rigidity.
The letter of intent may limit the flexibility of the
parties' positions and negatively impact the negotiation
process. A party seeking to renegotiate term will be
at a disadvantage once these points are incorporated
into a letter of intent, even if supposedly "non-binding."
3. Bad faith
liability.
Some letters of intent includes a provision that requires
the parties to negotiate unresolved terms in good faith.
In such instances, some courts have found that this
duty to negotiate unresolved terms in good faith may
impose liability on parties who are deemed to have acted
in bad faith or who refused to negotiate in good faith.
4. Risk of
disclosure of trade secrets and confidential information
Even with confidentiality provisions, the risk is present
that a party and/or its representatives may make improper
disclosures of confidential information or trade secrets.
It is also possible that if the transaction is not consummated,
the disclosed confidential information may be used to
compete against the exposed party.
Conclusion
A letter of intent certainly has its place in today's
business. In fact, it can be extremely useful at times.
The important thing is to understand what its legal
significance is and whether you are, or are not, bound
by execution of it. It is important to have your attorney
review the document carefully, explain its contents
and advise whether you should or should not execute
such a document.
Disclaimer